"In the comfort of" or "at the comfort of"?

Solution 1:

The preposition is applying to the comfort, not to the location. So it would be:

We ordered in comfort. (correct)

We ordered at comfort.

Another example:

We sat in the light of the moon.

Here it is hopefully more clear that you're talking about sitting in the light rather than in the moon!

Solution 2:

The first is definitely correct.

Although you are AT your home, your are IN comfort.