The more...the more structure with normal clause?
Solution 1:
It seems like there's another implied the more...
before the second clause
The more they sing, [the more] their burden lightens and their love deepens.
This answer explains the syntax of these expressions.
However, I've never heard of omitting one of the more
s in such an expression. If you don't want to use that format, you could say:
As they sing, their burden lightens and their love deepens.