What is the difference between the ARM, Thumb and Thumb 2 instruction encodings?

I am a bit confused about instruction sets. There are Thumb, ARM and Thumb 2. From what I have read Thumb instructions are all 16-bit but inside the ARMv7M user manual (page vi) there are Thumb 16-bit and Thumb 32-bit instructions mentioned.

Now I have to overcome this confusion. It is said that Thumb 2 supports 16-bit and 32-bit instructions. So is ARMv7M in fact supporting Thumb 2 instructions and not just Thumb?

One more thing. Can I say that Thumb (32-bit) is the same as ARM instructions which are allso 32-bit?

Solution 1:

Oh, ARM and their silly naming...

It's a common misconception, but officially there's no such thing as a "Thumb-2 instruction set".

Ignoring ARMv8 (where everything is renamed and AArch64 complicates things), from ARMv4T to ARMv7-A there are two instruction sets: ARM and Thumb. They are both "32-bit" in the sense that they operate on up-to-32-bit-wide data in 32-bit-wide registers with 32-bit addresses. In fact, where they overlap they represent the exact same instructions - it is only the instruction encoding which differs, and the CPU effectively just has two different decode front-ends to its pipeline which it can switch between. For clarity, I shall now deliberately avoid the terms "32-bit" and "16-bit"...

ARM instructions have fixed-width 4-byte encodings which require 4-byte alignment. Thumb instructions have variable-length (2 or 4-byte, now known as "narrow" and "wide") encodings requiring 2-byte alignment - most instructions have 2-byte encodings, but bl and blx have always had 4-byte encodings^*. The really confusing bit came in ARMv6T2, which introduced "Thumb-2 Technology". Thumb-2 encompassed not just adding a load more instructions to Thumb (mostly with 4-byte encodings) to bring it almost to parity with ARM, but also extending the execution state to allow for conditional execution of most Thumb instructions, and finally introducing a whole new assembly syntax (UAL, "Unified Assembly Language") which replaced the previous separate ARM and Thumb syntaxes and allowed writing code once and assembling it to either instruction set without modification.

The Cortex-M architectures only implement the Thumb instruction set - ARMv7-M (Cortex-M3/M4/M7) supports most of "Thumb-2 Technology", including conditional execution and encodings for VFP instructions, whereas ARMv6-M (Cortex-M0/M0+) only uses Thumb-2 in the form of a handful of 4-byte system instructions.

Thus, the new 4-byte encodings (and those added later in ARMv7 revisions) are still Thumb instructions - the "Thumb-2" aspect of them is that they can have 4-byte encodings, and that they can (mostly) be conditionally executed via it (and, I suppose, that their menmonics are only defined in UAL).

_{* Before ARMv6T2, it was actually a complicated implementation detail as to whether bl (or blx) was executed as a 4-byte instruction or as a pair of 2-byte instructions. The architectural definition was the latter, but since they could only ever be executed as a pair in sequence there was little to lose (other than the ability to take an interrupt halfway through) by fusing them into a single instruction for performance reasons. ARMv6T2 just redefined things in terms of the fused single-instruction execution}

Solution 2:

In addition to Notlikethat's answer, and as it hints at, ARMv8 introduces some new terminology to try to reduce the confusion (of course adding even more new terminology):

There is a 32-bit execution state (AArch32) and a 64-bit execution state (AArch64).

The 32-bit execution state supports two different instruction sets: T32 ("Thumb") and A32 ("ARM"). The 64-bit execution state supports only one instruction set - A64.

All A64, like all A32, instructions are 32-bit (4 byte) in size, requiring 4-byte alignment.

Many/most A64 instructions can operate on both 32-bit and 64-bit registers (or arguably 32-bit or 64-bit views of the same underlying 64-bit register).

All ARMv8 processors (like all ARMv7 processors) that implement AArch32 support Thumb-2 instructions in the T32 instruction set.

Not all ARMv8-A processors implement AAarch32, and some don't implement AArch64. Some Processors support both, but only support AArch32 at lower exception levels.

Solution 3:

Thumb: 16 bit instruction set

ARM: 32 bit wide instruction set hence more flexible instructions and less code density

Thumb2 (mixed 16/32 bit): somehow a compromise between ARM and thumb(16) (mixing them), to get both performance/flexibility of ARM and instruction density of Thumb. so a Thumb2 instruction can be either an ARM (only a subset of) with 32 bit wide instruction or a Thumb instruction with 16 bit wide.