Extracting multiple values from a sentence in single cell with same preceding value. eg. Player 1, Player 2

As the OP is using Google Sheets, there are Google Sheets' functions that will help extract the output.

  1. Insert another column. It will be used to display the results.
  2. In this example the inputs are in column A, the outputs are in column B. In cell B2, enter the formula:
=JOIN(CHAR(10), REGEXEXTRACT(A1,REGEXREPLACE(A1,"(Player \d+)","($1)")))

Drag the formula to fill the other cells.

Result - Google Sheets