What's the point of JAXB 2's ObjectFactory classes?
Backward compatibility isn't the only reason. :-P
With more complicated schemas, such as ones that have complicated constraints on the values that an element's contents can take on, sometimes you need to create actual JAXBElement objects. They are not usually trivial to create by hand, so the create* methods do the hard work for you. Example (from the XHTML 1.1 schema):
@XmlElementDecl(namespace = "http://www.w3.org/1999/xhtml", name = "style", scope = XhtmlHeadType.class)
public JAXBElement<XhtmlStyleType> createXhtmlHeadTypeStyle(XhtmlStyleType value) {
return new JAXBElement<XhtmlStyleType>(_XhtmlHeadTypeStyle_QNAME, XhtmlStyleType.class, XhtmlHeadType.class, value);
}
This is how you get a <style> tag into a <head> tag:
ObjectFactory factory = new ObjectFactory();
XhtmlHtmlType html = factory.createXhtmlHtmlType();
XhtmlHeadType head = factory.createXhtmlHeadType();
html.setHead(head);
XhtmlStyleType style = factory.createXhtmlStyleType();
head.getContent().add(factory.createXhtmlHeadTypeStyle(style));
The first three uses of the ObjectFactory could be considered superfluous (though useful for consistency), but the fourth one makes JAXB much, much easier to use. Imaging having to write a new JAXBElement out by hand each time!
As @Chris pointed out, sometimes JAXB cannot work with POJOs, because the schema cannot be mapped exactly on to Java. In these cases, JAXBElement wrapper objects are necessary to provide the additional type information.
There are two concrete examples that I've come across where this is common.
If you want to marshal an object of a class that does not have the
@XmlRootElementannotation. By default XJC only generates@XmlRootElementfor some elements, and not for others. The exact logic for this is a bit complicated, but you can force XJC to generate more@XmlRootElementclasses using the "simple binding mode"When your schema uses substituion groups. This is pretty advanced schema usage, but XJC translates substitution groups into Java by making heavy use of
JAXBElementwrappers.
So in an XJC-generated object model which makes heavy use of JAXBElement (for whatever reason), you need a way of constructing those JAXBElement instances. The generated ObjectFactory is by far the easiest way to do it. You can construct them yourself, but it's clunky and error-prone to do so.
Backwards compatibility, I guess ...
http://weblogs.java.net/blog/kohsuke/archive/2005/08/a_story_of_migr.html:
...No more ObjectFactory.createXYZ. The problem with those factory methods was that they throw a checked JAXBException. Now you can simply do new XYZ(), no more try/catch blocks. (I know, I know, ... this is one of those "what were we thinking!?" things)...