Return value range of the main function
What does standard say about main return values range? Say only up to 255?
Because
int main(void){
return 256;
}
echo $? ; # out 0
The standard doesn't say. 0
, EXIT_SUCCESS
and EXIT_FAILURE
have (sort of) specified meanings. Anything else depends on the implementation.
At the present time, most Unix-based systems only support 8-bit return values. Windows supports (at least) a 32-bit return value. I haven't checked whether 64-bit Windows supports a 64-bit return value, but I rather doubt it, since even 64-bit Windows normally still uses a 32-bit int.
As others have stated, the C & C++ Standards don't constrain return values at all other than to state that
-
main()
returns anint
(which is of an implementation defined size), and - zero (or
EXIT_SUCCESS
) is a successful return andEXIT_FAILURE
is a non-successful return.
It does specify that a main()
that does explicitly not return a value is treated as if it had returned zero.
In this case, the interpretation of the return value is up to the process that waits on the process to complete (by calling wait()
, waitpid()
, or waitid()
). wait()
and waitpid()
are the older POSIX functions and they specify that only the least significant eight bits of the return value shall be available to a waiting parent process. The POSIX:2008 standard added waitid()
as a generalized wait method that has access to the full exit status of a child process.
After forking off a subprocess, the parent process calls one of the wait*()
functions to sleep until the forked process is completed (e.g., returns from main()
, calls exit()
or abort()
or something). The wait()
and waitpid()
functions return the status by way of a pointer to an integer. The caller extracts the actual exit status using the WIFEXITED(status_val)
and WEXITSTATUS(status_val)
macros. The latter is defined by POSIX and required to return the low-order 8 bits of the status argument. The waitid()
function uses a pointer to a siginfo_t
structure to return the process's status information. The si_status
member contains the full status value as described in Status Information.
Basically, the values of the exit status are in the eye of the beholder. The ANSI/ISO specifications are open-ended. The POSIX suite has multiple ways to wait on a process to finish and fetch it's exit status. POSIX also defines spawn()
as a lighter-weight version of exec()
which has its own set of constraints on exit status values. Shells have a habit of further restricting result values -- GNU's bash limits the return status to 7 bits and a POSIX-compliant shell limits exit status values to 8 bits. FWIW, most people agree that restricting your return values to be lower than 64 seems to be safe.