Is it safe (or advisable) to compress Windows Installer folder via NTFS compression?

Solution 1:

Except for speed issues (there is a lot of discussion here on that topic with some saying it is actually beneficial to performance in some ways) there is no issues in using NTFS compression a current Windows installation disk and all it's folders in it.

• Your files are there, available, they do not really change to a secret compressed file or something, this is done at the file system level
• Performance is not worst depending on opinions and some tests
• They are recoverable using the Windows repair utilities or by connecting your disk to another computer (besides, nothing important is ever kept inside c:\Windows, your important files should be else where...)

Microsoft has put together some guide-lines about NTFS compression, have a look at them.

I have used NTFS compression for ages now on complete file systems on several clients and Windows versions and never had an issue because of the compressed filesystem.

Solution 2:

Yes, there is nothing special about the Installer directory that requires them to be uncompressed.

In the old days, there were piles of installer files like unwise.exe, unvise32.exe, uninstall.exe, etc. in the \Windows\ directory; sometimes shared, sometimes not. The \Windows\Installer folder is the Windows Installer cache, which allows each program to maintain its own installation program, similar to how the WinSxS folder helps to avoid DLL Hell.

In general, it is used to store/cache the basic installer for programs, so that when you want to modify an installed program, it runs from there and allows you to uninstall or possibly even do a repair without needing the original installation media, and so there should be no adverse affects from setting it to use NTFS compression.

Some programs choose to store their entire installer which of course is undesirable, but fortunately those are rare; most just store a smaller installer file (like unwise32.exe in the old days) with the basic installation information. Most programs don’t use the files in the Installer folder at all and they only come into play when you make a change with Add/Remove Programs.

Occasionally however, you may find a program that actively uses some of the files, particularly by setting the icon of their shortcuts (in the Start menu, desktop, etc.) to point to the ARPPRODUCTICON.exe file in its Installer cache.

In most cases, you can compress or move the files and put them back when you want to make a change (modify, repair, uninstall). In fact, the folder is ultimately a cache of installation files, so you could even delete them and just use the original installation media.

NB: it is not only programs that cache their installation files in the Installer folder; Windows itself keeps patches and service-pack data in there as well, so if you delete them, updates may not work, and theoretically, you might have to re-install Windows. Don’t just move/delete the entire contents willy-nilly; take a look at what is in there.