Workarounds for "cp -p" not preserving nanoseconds on High Sierra with APFS?
I don't know if this affects MacOS versions newer than High Sierra, but it seems that cp -p
won't preserve timestamps with nanoseconds resolution.
Because of this, the shell can wrongly tell that a file is older than other even if it was copied by cp -p
. This breaks build system dependencies when some files were installed by cp -p
: they keep reinstalling and reinstalling again because the nanoseconds don't match.
Can you suggest some workaround for this? I thought compiling my own cp
binary, but however cp
is usually a shell builtin, and moreover I'm not aware of any nanosecond-preserving cp
version out there.
Note: I know of a workaround, but it's not reasonable: Execute touch
on the source file before executing cp -p
. Because touch
doesn't preserve nanoseconds either, it makes them zero on the source file, so the result after cp -p
guarantees exactly the same timestamp. However, as I said, it's not reasonable, because I don't like to touch
files just for this: you lose their real last saved date.
Good to know that I'm not the only one who thinks this is a problem. I ran into it while writing a Python script for monitoring parts of my macOS (10.15.7) filesystem, which also involved coping files. The script sometimes behaved erratic and produced unpredictable output. After some poking around I found out that the incapability of cp -p
to preserve nanoseconds is the core of the problem.
One workaround for your problem (but not for mine) could be coreutils
: gcp -p
behaves as intended.
I thought this was fixed in 10.15, but I just didn't repro the problem correctly. To save others the same embarrassment, here's a repro that shows the problem:
% python3 -c 'open("file1", "w")'
% stat -f %Fm file1
1609301645.481666557
% cp -p file1 file2
% stat -f %Fm file2
1609301645.481666000