Is using Software Updater the same thing as running apt-get update and apt-get upgrade?

Solution 1:

Short answer

No, they are not the same. apt-get upgrade doesn't handle changing dependencies between versions, so if a package has changed dependencies, it wont be upgraded (it'll be "held back"). See the long answer for more details.

Using the Software Updater and using sudo apt-get update ; sudo apt-get dist-upgrade (note the dist-) would be almost equivalent, except that one's obviously a GUI and the other's a console application and also a few very minor informational differences.

Long asnwer

From man apt-get,

• apt-get upgrade:

  upgrade
             upgrade is used to install the newest versions of all packages
             currently installed on the system from the sources enumerated in
             /etc/apt/sources.list. Packages currently installed with new
             versions available are retrieved and upgraded; under no
             circumstances are currently installed packages removed, or packages
             not already installed retrieved and installed. New versions of
             currently installed packages that cannot be upgraded without
             changing the install status of another package will be left at
             their current version. An update must be performed first so that
             apt-get knows that new versions of packages are available.

  (emphasis by me)

  This means that a newer version of a package which has a new dependency not required in the old version will not be upgraded with this method (unless the new dependency was already installed). These will be shown as "Held back".

• apt-get dist-upgrade:

  dist-upgrade
         dist-upgrade in addition to performing the function of upgrade,
         also intelligently handles changing dependencies with new versions
         of packages; apt-get has a "smart" conflict resolution system, and
         it will attempt to upgrade the most important packages at the
         expense of less important ones if necessary. The dist-upgrade
         command may therefore remove some packages. The
         /etc/apt/sources.list file contains a list of locations from which
         to retrieve desired package files. See also apt_preferences(5) for
         a mechanism for overriding the general settings for individual
         packages.

  (emphasis by me)

  This means that with this command instead of upgrade, packages with new (or removed) dependencies can by upgraded.

Example

A good example of the difference between the two is when a new Linux kernel is released. This is packaged into the linux-image-generic package which always depends on the latest package of the Linux kernel. Because the dependencies of linux-image-generic change with each kernel upgrade, upgrade wont upgrade it.

Solution 2:

It's nearly the same but not exactly. For example, when kernel updates are offered, sudo apt-get update && sudo apt-get dist-upgrade is needed to get those updates.

sudo apt-get update && sudo apt-get upgrade will tell you that some packages have been held back.

Using the Software Updater makes everything seamless and you won't see anything held back.