Unable to play Age of Empires: Rise of Rome over LAN in Windows 10

Solution 1:

Since Rise of Rome connects successfully with Windows 7 and this latter is obviously connected through local ip 192.168.0.11 which is the ip for "Wireless network connection"

Now the The reason for you are seeing two local ips in Windows 10 is that you have two network connections enabled. And rise of rome is picking two local ips from two network connections but most definitely only using the first ip on that list.

Only keep "Wireless network connection" which is your Wifi internet But disable the rest.

Windows 10 & Windows Defender

Windows 10 comes with an integrated Antivirus(Windows Defender) + Windows Firewall. So you must add your game exe file to both Windows Defender + Windows Firewall. Doing so ensures that the game won't be interrupted or slowed down or blocked.

An Observation

The screenshot you took for windows 7 static ip shows a different local ip format 192.168.0.X which means your gateway or router address should be 192.168.0.1. Your local PC ip (based on your image) is 192.168.0.11.

So make sure your windows 10 local ip address is of the same format too. And do not leave the Default Gateway: empty. Fill it with 192.168.0.1