Emulating CSS3 border-radius and box-shadow in IE7/8

Solution 1:

Check out this post: http://www.smashingmagazine.com/2010/04/28/css3-solutions-for-internet-explorer/

It covers specifically rounded corners and box shadow for CSS3 in IE7/8.

Solution 2:

This is my method, I use the conditionals to target CSS files to IE browsers.

Say you have your div with the id #page_container. In your regular master.css or css3.css file, you would give it your width, height, rounded corners and drop shadow with styles.

Now, when IE hits your page, it will pull in the condition css you had set up. For that same div#page_container, you may alter the width a bit, height, maybe some padding, then give it a background-image to make it look like the drop shadow, rounded-corner version.

So your head will have this:

<head>
<link rel="stylesheet" type="text/css" href="master.css" />
<!--[if lte IE 8]> <link rel="stylesheet" type="text/css" href="ie.css" /> <![endif]-->
</head>

In the master.css file, you would have this definition for your main div:

div#page_container {
  width: 960px;
  height: auto;
  padding: 10px 10px 10px 10px;
  background: #ccc;
  drop-shadow: whatever...
  rounded-corner: whatever...
}

Now, in your ie.css file, and because it is referenced in your second, the definition will cascade down so you can alter it a bit:

div#page_container {
  width: 960px;
  height: auto;
  padding: 15px 15px 15px 15px; /* this is key */
  background: #ccc url(/path/to/image.file) no-repeat top left;
}

Add just enough extra padding so the drop shadows fit in with your background-image. Because it cascades down, it will overwrite the original 10px padding you had, expanding the box model to fit in your extra shadow graphics.

Couple benefits to this method include:

Only IE will see this definition and the call to the image. If this is a high volume app, that will save on bandwidth and any delays associated with the call.
Likewise, because you didn't hard code in the rounded corner graphics that every browser would see, your Firefox and Safari users won't need hit the server with extra image calls.
No need to add in yet another javascript plug-in that checks for IE, creates new markup, time, etc...

Solution 3:

First of all I like to mention that there is no perfect solution for this until IE9, where the CSS border-radius is gonna be implemented.

Here are the different solutions you have until then:

You could use one of many JS scripts that simulates rounded corners. But none of them implement the shadow properly. Here is the list of the scripts i tried and my conclusions. All of this scripts have something in common, they are placing additional elements in your HTML to give you the illusion of rounded corners.

DD Roundies: This script is very lightweight an works pretty well. It works without any framework and plays nice with jQuery & Prototype (i assume its working well with the others to, but i can't tell for sure). It uses the CSS3 proprieties on browsers who support CSS3. And uses the same hack as all the others for IE. The antialiazing on this one works very good. edit i have to correct my self here. This one works with a HTC File. It does not placing additional elements in your HTML.
Curvy Corners and the jQuery Plugin Curvy Corners: I like this one to. The antialiazing is working very good to. And it plays nice with background images. But it does not play nice with CSS3 shadows. It does not check if your Browser support CSS3 and always uses the ugly solution of adding elements to your dom.
Nifty Corners & jquery Corner: Both have a bad antialiazing and the corners look very edgy. jQuery corners has trouble to handle background images.

Here is the reason why none of them is a proper solution in my opinion:

curvy corners dom messing screenshot http://meodai.ch/stackoverflow/curvy.png curvy dom mess

nifty dom mess http://meodai.ch/stackoverflow/nifty.png nifty dom mess

There are a few other but i think they are not mentionable at this place.

As you can see they are adding a lot of elements to your dom. This can cause trouble if you want to add rounded corners to a huge amount of elements. It can make some older browser / computers crash. For the shadows its pretty much the same problem. There is a jQuery plugin that handles shadows on boxes and fonts: http://dropshadow.webvex.limebits.com/

My conclusion: If i am doing a small budget job, IE users just have edges and no shadows. If the client has some money to spend, so i am doing it with CSS only and i make images for every corner. If they absolutely have to be there but there is no time or no money to do it, i use one of the mentioned JS Scripts DD_roundies with preference. Now its up to you.

PS: IE users are used to ugly interfaces, they don't gonna see that the corners and shadows are missing anyway :P

Emulating CSS3 border-radius and box-shadow in IE7/8

Solution 1:

Solution 2:

Solution 3:

Related

Recent Posts