Is this sentence “derogatory”? [closed]
Is this sentence “derogatory”?
He just gave me the biggest fuck you of my career.
Intuitively it doesn't seem to rise to the level of derogatory; merely the use of a vulgar idiom. But what words would successfully counter the argument that it is a derogatory statement?
Solution 1:
The sentence itself merely reports the situation, so it's a case of a use–mention distinction. You are mentioning an expression (or metaphor) someone else used. It would be normal to make the distinction clear by either using quotes or italics:
- He just gave me the biggest "fuck you" of my career.
- He just gave me the biggest fuck you of my career.
...depending on whether "Fuck you" was actually said or it's a metaphor for what was done.
I agree that the sentence is vulgar. But it may be reporting a derogatory or insulting [and vulgar] remark.
Solution 2:
If you said the sentence to someone concerning third party's action, you would not necessarily be making a derogatory comment about either the listener or the third party.
It would indicate that you are not entirely pleased with the third party's actions.