Autowiring two beans implementing same interface - how to set default bean to autowire?

Background:

I have a Spring 2.5/Java/Tomcat application. There is the following bean, which is used throughout the application in many places

public class HibernateDeviceDao implements DeviceDao

and the following bean which is new:

public class JdbcDeviceDao implements DeviceDao

The first bean is configured so (all beans in the package are included)

<context:component-scan base-package="com.initech.service.dao.hibernate" />

The second (new) bean is configured separately

<bean id="jdbcDeviceDao" class="com.initech.service.dao.jdbc.JdbcDeviceDao">
    <property name="dataSource" ref="jdbcDataSource">
</bean>

This results (of course) in an exception when starting the server:

nested exception is org.springframework.beans.factory.NoSuchBeanDefinitionException: No unique bean of type [com.sevenp.mobile.samplemgmt.service.dao.DeviceDao] is defined: expected single matching bean but found 2: [deviceDao, jdbcDeviceDao]

from a class trying to autowire the bean like this

@Autowired
private DeviceDao hibernateDevicDao;

because there are two beans implementing the same interface.

The question:

Is it possible to configure the beans so that

1. I don't have to make changes to existing classes, which already have the HibernateDeviceDao autowired

2. still being able to use the second (new) bean like this:

@Autowired
@Qualifier("jdbcDeviceDao")

I.e. i would need a way to configure the HibernateDeviceDao bean as the default bean to be autowired, simultaneously allowing the usage of a the JdbcDeviceDao when explicitly specifying so with the @Qualifier annotation.

What I've already tried:

I tried setting the property

autowire-candidate="false"

in the bean configuration for JdbcDeviceDao:

<bean id="jdbcDeviceDao" class="com.initech.service.dao.jdbc.JdbcDeviceDao" autowire-candidate="false">
    <property name="dataSource" ref="jdbcDataSource"/>
</bean>

because the Spring documentation says that

Indicates whether or not this bean should be considered when looking for matching candidates to satisfy another bean's autowiring requirements. Note that this does not affect explicit references by name, which will get resolved even if the specified bean is not marked as an autowire candidate.*

which I interpreted to mean that I could still autowire JdbcDeviceDao using the @Qualifier annotation and have the HibernateDeviceDao as default bean. Apparently my interpretation was not correct, though, as this results in the following error message when starting the server:

Unsatisfied dependency of type [class com.sevenp.mobile.samplemgmt.service.dao.jdbc.JdbcDeviceDao]: expected at least 1 matching bean

coming from the class where I've tried autowiring the bean with a qualifier:

@Autowired
@Qualifier("jdbcDeviceDao")

Solution:

skaffman's suggestion to try the @Resource annotation worked. So the configuration has autowire-candidate set to false for jdbcDeviceDao and when using the jdbcDeviceDao I refer to it using the @Resource annotation (instead of @Qualifier):

@Resource(name = "jdbcDeviceDao")
private JdbcDeviceListItemDao jdbcDeviceDao;

Solution 1:

I'd suggest marking the Hibernate DAO class with @Primary, i.e. (assuming you used @Repository on HibernateDeviceDao):

@Primary
@Repository
public class HibernateDeviceDao implements DeviceDao

This way it will be selected as the default autowire candididate, with no need to autowire-candidate on the other bean.

Also, rather than using @Autowired @Qualifier, I find it more elegant to use @Resource for picking specific beans, i.e.

@Resource(name="jdbcDeviceDao")
DeviceDao deviceDao;

Solution 2:

What about @Primary?

Indicates that a bean should be given preference when multiple candidates are qualified to autowire a single-valued dependency. If exactly one 'primary' bean exists among the candidates, it will be the autowired value. This annotation is semantically equivalent to the <bean> element's primary attribute in Spring XML.

@Primary
public class HibernateDeviceDao implements DeviceDao

Or if you want your Jdbc version to be used by default:

<bean id="jdbcDeviceDao" primary="true" class="com.initech.service.dao.jdbc.JdbcDeviceDao">

@Primary is also great for integration testing when you can easily replace production bean with stubbed version by annotating it.

Solution 3:

For Spring 2.5, there's no @Primary. The only way is to use @Qualifier.