ALTER TABLE on dependent column

I am trying to alter column datatype of a primary key to tinyint from int.This column is a foreign key in other tables.So,I get the following error:


Msg 5074, Level 16, State 1, Line 1 The object 'PK_User_tbl' is dependent on column 'appId'. Msg 5074, Level 16, State 1, Line 1 The object 'FK_Details_tbl_User_tbl' is dependent on column 'appId'. Msg 5074, Level 16, State 1, Line 1 The object 'FK_Log_tbl_User_tbl' is dependent on column 'appId'. Msg 4922, Level 16, State 9, Line 1 ALTER TABLE ALTER COLUMN appId failed because one or more objects access this column.


Is there any other way other than to delete dependencies and recreate them?


I believe that you will have to drop the foreign key constraints first. Then update all of the appropriate tables and remap them as they were.

ALTER TABLE [dbo.Details_tbl] DROP CONSTRAINT [FK_Details_tbl_User_tbl];
-- Perform more appropriate alters
ALTER TABLE [dbo.Details_tbl] ADD FOREIGN KEY (FK_Details_tbl_User_tbl) 
    REFERENCES User_tbl(appId);
-- Perform all appropriate alters to bring the key constraints back

However, unless memory is a really big issue, I would keep the identity as an INT. Unless you are 100% positive that your keys will never grow past the TINYINT restraints. Just a word of caution :)


If your constraint is on a user type, then don't forget to see if there is a Default Constraint, usually something like DF__TableName__ColumnName__6BAEFA67, if so then you will need to drop the Default Constraint, like this:

ALTER TABLE TableName DROP CONSTRAINT [DF__TableName__ColumnName__6BAEFA67]

For more info see the comments by the brilliant Aaron Bertrand on this answer.