Android: RunOnUiThread vs AsyncTask
I believe Google suggests developers to use AsyncTask. However, I would like to know how is it different from using 'new Thread' and then calling 'RunOnUiThread' in performance and memory efficiency.
Example for using RunOnUithread:
// some code #1
Thread t = new Thread("Thread1") {
@Override
public void run() {
// some code #2
runOnUiThread(new Runnable() {
public void run() {
// some code #3 (that needs to be ran in UI thread)
}
});
}
};
t.start();
vs.
AsyncTask:
onPreExecute() {
// some code #1
}
doInBackground() {
// some code #2
}
onPostExecute() {
// some code #3
}
What are the advantages / disadvantages?
Edit:
I am not looking for answers like 'easier to see the code', 'convenient for developers' etc. I am actually looking for technical diffrences behind the scene.
For example, Paul Nikonowicz's answer below would have been the answer I wanted to see. (But AsyncTask behaves the same)
When you use new Thread
you're really creating a new thread every time you execute that. AsyncTask
however, uses a static pool of max 128 threads and will reuse an old thread whenever it exists. So, running AsyncTask 10 times in serial will only create one thread that runs the task 10 times instead of 10 threads.
That's one of the differences among many.
It's a convenience, essentially. The AsyncTask
framework deals with managing the Thread
pool and provides a simple, understandable interface. It's well-known -- by those that know how to use AsyncTask
-- that UI activity can go on in onPreExecute()
, onPostExecute()
and onProgressUpdate()
, and that all of the "heavy lifting" is done in doInBackground()
where you can't touch the UI.
It makes it easy for a developer to have a simple background task that can easily post updates to the UI thread and return results when done. It's not magic, it's just a convenience.
According to this, AsyncTask
is easier to use, but has some limitations like the following:
- Core pool size and Work queue is fixed: 5 pools / 10 elements
- it's hard coded and can't be changed
- Thread priority is fixed to low
- Exception handling is not as well supported as with
Thread
Also there will be another difference that I haven't figured out. You can find and inspect full source code of AsyncTask since Android is opensource :-)
Have a good time with coding in Android!