Is there any difference between the `:key => "value"` and `key: "value"` hash notations?

Is there any difference between :key => "value" (hashrocket) and key: "value" (Ruby 1.9) notations?

If not, then I would like to use key: "value" notation. Is there a gem that helps me to convert from :x => to x: notations?


Yes, there is a difference. These are legal:

h = { :$in => array }
h = { :'a.b' => 'c' }
h[:s] = 42

but these are not:

h = { $in: array }
h = { 'a.b': 'c' } # but this is okay in Ruby2.2+
h[s:] = 42

You can also use anything as a key with => so you can do this:

h = { C.new => 11 }
h = { 23 => 'pancakes house?' }

but you can't do this:

h = { C.new: 11 }
h = { 23: 'pancakes house?' }

The JavaScript style (key: value) is only useful if all of your Hash keys are "simple" symbols (more or less something that matches /\A[a-z_]\w*\z/i, AFAIK the parser uses its label pattern for these keys).

The :$in style symbols show up a fair bit when using MongoDB so you'll end up mixing Hash styles if you use MongoDB. And, if you ever work with specific keys of Hashes (h[:k]) rather than just whole hashes (h = { ... }), you'll still have to use the colon-first style for symbols; you'll also have to use the leading-colon style for symbols that you use outside of Hashes. I prefer to be consistent so I don't bother with the JavaScript style at all.

Some of the problems with the JavaScript-style have been fixed in Ruby 2.2. You can now use quotes if you have symbols that aren't valid labels, for example:

h = { 'where is': 'pancakes house?', '$set': { a: 11 } }

But you still need the hashrocket if your keys are not symbols.


key: "value" is a convenience feature of Ruby 1.9; so long as you know your environment will support it, I see no reason not to use it. It's just much easier to type a colon than a rocket, and I think it looks much cleaner. As for there being a gem to do the conversion, probably not, but it seems like an ideal learning experience for you, if you don't already know file manipulation and regular expressions.


Ruby hash-keys assigned by hash-rockets can facilitate strings for key-value pairs (e.g. 's' => x) whereas key assignment via symbols (e.g. key: "value" or :key => "value") cannot be assigned with strings. Although hash-rockets provide freedom and functionality for hash-tables, specifically allowing strings as keys, application performance may be slower than if the hash-tables were to be constructed with symbols as hash-keys. The following resources may be able to clarify any differences between hashrockets and symbols:

  • Ryan Sobol's Symbols in Ruby
  • Ruby Hashes Exaplained by Erik Trautman