What is the difference between children and childNodes in JavaScript?
Solution 1:
Understand that .children
is a property of an Element. 1 Only Elements have .children
, and these children are all of type Element. 2
However, .childNodes
is a property of Node. .childNodes
can contain any node. 3
A concrete example would be:
let el = document.createElement("div");
el.textContent = "foo";
el.childNodes.length === 1; // Contains a Text node child.
el.children.length === 0; // No Element children.
Most of the time, you want to use .children
because generally you don't want to loop over Text or Comment nodes in your DOM manipulation.
If you do want to manipulate Text nodes, you probably want .textContent
instead. 4
1. Technically, it is an attribute of ParentNode, a mixin included by Element.
2. They are all elements because .children
is a HTMLCollection, which can only contain elements.
3. Similarly, .childNodes
can hold any node because it is a NodeList.
4. Or .innerText
. See the differences here or here.
Solution 2:
Element.children
returns only element children, while Node.childNodes
returns all node children. Note that elements are nodes, so both are available on elements.
I believe childNodes
is more reliable. For example, MDC (linked above) notes that IE only got children
right in IE 9. childNodes
provides less room for error by browser implementors.