How do you gauge the Near Pin % of a transaction?
Searching around on the internet, I've found that apparently the best percentage to enter in order to get the most Near Pin bonuses is 104% if you want to get the most out of Near/Full Pin bonuses for Merchant/Customer experience levels. Each customer has a different percentage that they are willing to pay up to. For example, you may have noticed the Little Girl is an incredible cheapskate, while the Guild Master has a considerably larger budget.
Customer Max Exp+rep Max Profit Max Exp+rep Max Profit (selling) (selling) (buying) (buying) Girl 104% 112%(?) 70% 52% Woman 104% 118% 70% 52% Old Man 104% 118% 70% 44% Man 104% 127% 70% 39% Guild Master 104% 127% 70% 41% Louie 104% 118% 70% 38% Charme 104% 127% 70% 47%
Information is from this google doc, which has a more detailed collection of collected statistics overall about the game.