clang vs gcc - CTAD of struct deriving from template parameter

Consider the following code:

template <typename B>
struct D : B { };

D d{[]{ }};

• gcc 12.x accepts it and deduces d to be D</* type of lambda */> as expected.

• clang 14.x rejects it with the following error:

<source>:4:3: error: no viable constructor 
              or deduction guide for deduction of template arguments of 'D'
D d{[]{ }};
  ^

<source>:2:8: note: candidate template ignored: 
              could not match 'D<B>' against '(lambda at <source>:4:5)'
struct D : B { };
       ^

<source>:2:8: note: candidate function template not viable: 
              requires 0 arguments, but 1 was provided

live example on godbolt.org

Which compiler is behaving correctly here?

Solution 1:

In the code snippet, no deduction guide has been provided. P1816 added deduction guides for aggregate class templates in C++20, by requiring that an aggregate deduction candidate is generated.

The code is valid, but Clang just doesn't support P1816 yet.

Adding a deduction guide allows this to compile in Clang as well.

template <typename B> D(B) -> D<B>;