Everything says Applocker is supposed to work: Why doesn't it?

I've setup a basic group policy consisting of the default Applocker rules. Per Microsoft's technet article on the subject, any files not explicitly allowed to run by the policy are supposed to be blocked from running. After deploying this policy and verifying it was being applied to the correct user using gpresult, I was still able to download and run an exe from the internet, an exe that was saved to the user profile's temp folder. It was at that point I did more googling, and saw that the App Identity service had to be running, and it wasn't: So, like any good admin, I started it, set it to automatic, and rebooted just in case. The policy still didn't work after restarting. Below is a screenshot of the current policy.

I added the deny rules explicitly because the default rules weren't working. I correctly applied the policy to the machine and verified that the rules are enforced (it says so in the screenshot). I used the Test-AppLockerPolicy cmdlet to verify that the rule is should be blocking the EXEs and MSIs from running, but it doesn't. Open to most suggestions, no matter how ludicrous they may sound.

Update

Forgot to add that I checked the event log for AppLocker during this whole fiasco, and it was blank. Not a single entry the entire time.

If your path block was not defined correctly then that would explain you situation.

For example if you were to use the %userprofile% environment variable. There are only a subset of the environment variables available through GPO/AppLocker and that's not one of them.

I have had success with the following path rule:

%osdrive%\users\*

This is an old thread but I came across it when implementing AppLocker on our own network.

AppLocker requires the use of the Application Identity service, which is set to Manual on a default install of Win7/Server 2008 R2. You must set the Application Identity service to Automatic startup or the rules will not be enforced. You can do this with the Group Policy object where AppLocker rules are defined.