MariaDB Cluster vs Percona Cluster for MySQL

Solution 1:

Both platforms use the same mechanism for replication: Galera. On the page at that link, you'll notice there are images featuring both PXC and MariaDB Cluster.

Galera library provides transactional replication. MyISAM doesn't do transactions, so the problems you may be having now are very likely related and would not be any different on the alternate platform.

Currently replication works only with InnoDB storage engine. Any writes to tables of other types, including system (mysql.*) tables, are not replicated. However, DDL statements are replicated in statement level, and changes to mysql.* tables will get replicated that way. So, you can safely issue: CREATE USER..., but issuing: INSERT INTO mysql.user..., will not be replicated.

^{— http://www.percona.com/doc/percona-xtradb-cluster/limitation.html}

Currently MariaDB Galera Cluster only supports the InnoDB/XtraDB storage engine.

^{— https://mariadb.com/kb/en/getting-started-with-mariadb-galera-cluster/}

And, of course, PXC uses XtraDB, Percona's compatible replacement for InnoDB (it has "XtraDB" right in the name), and MariaDB also uses Percona's XtraDB instead of Oracle's InnoDB, although, for compatibility on both systems, the storage engine still calls itself InnoDB.

Since the two systems share a signficant amount of code and are all intended to be essentially drop-in replacements for one another, the decision of which platform to use is largely a matter of opinion. I personally prefer vendor "x" which might mean I'd personally recommend you use MariaDB and also might mean I'd personally recommend sticking with PXC, but I need not actually actually tell you my preference, since it doesn't matter -- it's based largely on opinions and impressions and documentation and personalities and not on any kind of valuable evidence.

Your best solution for migrating MyISAM is probably going to be to modify the dumpfiles to ENGINE=InnoDB (and any other changes that necessitates) or staging them on a standalone server, then converting and exporting them as fully-InnoDB before trying to import them to your cluster.

If the MyISAM issue is your only concern, or even just your primary concern, then MariaDB Cluster and PXC are essentially identical in that regard -- they don't support it, for a very sensible reason -- it's not feasible to do so.

Solution 2:

I work for Percona, so I'm biased. I'd say that while on the surface they are similar products, PXC has had many more releases, we're doing a ton more QA, and are doing much more to contribute back to Codership than Maria so far.

However, MyISAM support is going to be the same on either, and I'm sorry to say that if MyISAM is a design requirement for you, you're likely not going to be happy on any Galera product. Galera is simply never going to really support a non-transactional engine like MyISAM like it does with Innodb and I'd agree with Michael that migrating away from MyISAM is your best choice if you are moving to Galera.