Does Windows 7 restrict folder access as Vista does?

I noticed that in my application, most compatibility problems were caused by 'access denied' for some folders, such as:

Application Data [C:\ProgramData]
Desktop [C:\Users\Public\Desktop]
Documents [C:\Users\Public\Documents]
Favorites [C:\Users\Public\Favorites]
Start Menu [C:\ProgramData\Microsoft\Windows\Start Menu]
Templates [C:\ProgramData\Microsoft\Windows\Templates]

Does Windows 7 have the same problem as Vista? With help from the members of Stack Overflow, I know that on Vista I can use CSIDL_APPDATA to enable the file access without UAC problems or 'access denied' errors. Is this also valid for Windows 7?

Solution 1:

It's not a "problem", it's a feature. It's called User Account Control (UAC), and it's one of the ways that system security was tightened under Windows Vista. Windows 7 indeed retains a similar security model.

There's absolutely no reason that your application should need to mess with system folders in the first place. As you've already learned, Windows provides a number of locations for applications to store data, both temporarily and permanently. Microsoft has been recommending for a long time that you take advantage of these folders: they were the preferred location for storing data even under previous versions of Windows. The fact that you ignored this advice, yet your application continued to work, was actually the bug. The fact that later versions of Windows finally closed that security vulnerability, thus breaking your application, should be neither unexpected nor unappreciated.

You can find more information about where to store your data on this page. Also see this blog article, which attempts to summarize the array of technical documentation into a handy table. And as always, Raymond Chen provides a simple, yet instructive, overview of the differences between the locations:

The most important difference between My Documents and Application Data is that My Documents is where users store their files, whereas Application Data is where programs store their files.

In other words, if you put something in CSIDL_MYDOCUMENTS (My Documents), you should expect the user to be renaming it, moving it, deleting it, emailing it to their friends, all the sorts of things users do with their files. Therefore, files that go there should be things that users will recognize as "their stuff". Documents they've created, music they've downloaded, that sort of thing.

On the other hand, if you put something in CSIDL_APPDATA (Application Data), the user is less likely to be messing with it. This is where you put your program's supporting data that isn't really something you want the user messing with, but which should still be associated with the user. High score tables, program settings, customizations, spell check exceptions...

There is another directory called CSIDL_LOCAL_APPDATA (Local Settings\Application Data) which acts like CSIDL_APPDATA, except that it does not get copied if the user profile roams. (The "Local Settings" branch is not copied as part of the roaming user profile.) Think of it as a per-user-per-machine storage location. Caches and similar non-essential data should be kept here, especially if they are large. Other examples of non-roaming per-user data are your %TEMP% and Temporary Internet Files directories.