Why does an Intel RST RAID 1 array write faster with write-back cache disabled?

I have two HDDs (5900 RPM) in RAID 1 (mirror). I know, I know, it's painfully slow. I'm currently in the process of replacing them with faster drives, hence this question while I'm testing things.

For some reason, disabling write-back caching in the Intel RST options gives me much faster write speeds, and vice versa. From what I know, I'd expect write speeds to decrease with write-back caching disabled. Is that correct? Is this just a bug in the monitoring program?

Caching enabled:

Caching disabled:

Intel RST system report:

System Report

System Information
OS name:  Microsoft Windows 7 Professional 
OS version:  6.1.7601 Service Pack 1 7601
System name:  (redacted)
System manufacturer:  MSI
System model:  MS-7673
Processor:  GenuineIntel Intel64 Family 6 Model 42 Stepping 7 3.401  GHz
BIOS:  BIOS Date: 08/01/12 15:53:14 Ver: 04.06.04, ALASKA - 1072009

Intel® Rapid Storage Technology
Kit installed:  10.5.0.1007
User interface version:  10.5.0.1007
Language:  English (Australia)
Intel RAID controller:  Intel(R) Desktop/Workstation/Server Express Chipset SATA RAID Controller
Number of SATA ports:  6
RAID option ROM version:  10.5.0.1034
Driver version:  10.5.0.1007
ISDI version:  10.5.0.1007

Device Information
Name:  Array_0000
Size:  3.6 TB
Available space:  0 GB
Disk data cache:  Enabled
Number of volumes:  1
Volume member:  OS
Number of disks:  2
Array disk:  5YD2V3WZ
Array disk:  5YD2VEPK

Name:  OS
Status:  Normal
Type:  RAID 1
Size:  1.8 TB
Data stripe size:  64 KB
Write-back cache:  Enabled
System volume:  Yes  
Initialized:  Yes  
Verification errors found:  72
Blocks with media errors:  0
Physical sector size:  512 Bytes
Logical sector size:  512 Bytes
Parent array:  Array_0000
Number of disks:  2
Array disk:  5YD2V3WZ
Array disk:  5YD2VEPK

Disk on port 0
Port location:  Internal
Status:  Normal
Type:  Hard disk
Usage:  Array disk
Size:  1.8 TB
Serial number:  5YD2V3WZ
Model:  ST2000DL003-9VT166
Firmware:  CC32
System disk:  No
Password protected:  No
Disk data cache:  Enabled
Native command queuing:  Yes  
SATA transfer rate:  6 Gb/s
Physical sector size:  512 Bytes
Logical sector size:  512 Bytes

Disk on port 1
Port location:  Internal
Status:  Normal
Type:  Hard disk
Usage:  Array disk
Size:  1.8 TB
Serial number:  5YD2VEPK
Model:  ST2000DL003-9VT166
Firmware:  CC32
System disk:  No
Password protected:  No
Disk data cache:  Enabled
Native command queuing:  Yes  
SATA transfer rate:  6 Gb/s
Physical sector size:  512 Bytes
Logical sector size:  512 Bytes

(redacted other disks)

In Write-Back caching, the controller sends a data transfer completion signal to the host when the controller cache has received all the data in a transaction.

In Write-Through caching, the controller sends a data transfer completion signal to the host when the disk subsystem has received all the data in a transaction.

Write-Back caching has the following drawbacks:

• If block is to be replaced, write to main memory only if update bit is set
• I/O must access main memory through cache

References

• Cache Write Policies and Performance(pdf)

• Configuring and Managing RAID : CERC 6/i User's Guide

• Write-through Caching