Any Easy Solution to the Hands of Time Clock Puzzles?
In the temporal rifts that lead to mini-games, is there any easy solution or useful tricks to solving the clock puzzles? In general I resort to randomly choosing a few options and hoping they work out. I wanted to play an RPG - not Super Magic Happy Clocks, but I disgress...
I understand the basic concepts and I realize that each puzzle is randomly generated so there aren't pre-determined solutions. Any tips / advice is greatly welcomed.
There are a few hands of time solvers out there.
Personally i find these the best:
http://clockpuzzle.pl/ (its online so nothing to download)
or
http://www.mediafire.com/?dar4yh69lxcaavh
Doing it manually, I've found the best way to get a correct solution is to look at each number on the board, and mark which numbers it can be the next in the chain. Rather than continue the chain, I move onto the next number clockwise, until I've built a table of values. That table is usually enough to figure out the correct chain.
So, for example, take the following clock:
2
2 2
3 1
1
Assigning a letter to each number starting with the 2 at the top and working my way clockwise, I can generate a table like this:
A | B | C | D | E | F
--------------------------
A x | x | o | x | o | x
B o | x | o | x | x | x
C x | o | x | o | x | x
D x | o | x | x | x | o
E x | o | x | x | x | x
F x | o | x | o | x | x
From this, I can see that E must lead into B. By eliminating other choices as they become locked in the chain, I can arrive at the correct solution, which is:
A → E → B → C → D → F
This scales to any size clock, but it's tedious. So instead, I decided to write an automated solution in PHP:
<?php
// Supply clock values clockwise.
// Keys can be anything you want to use to remember the positions.
$clock = array(
'a' => 2,
'b' => 1,
'c' => 1,
'd' => 2,
'e' => 3,
'f' => 2,
);
$positions = array_keys($clock);
$values = array_values($clock);
// Test all possible starting positions.
for ($i = 0; $i < count($clock); ++$i) {
$chain = test_clock($values, $i);
// When the solution has all values, it's the right one.
if (count($chain) == count($clock)) {
break;
}
}
// Use the user-supplied keys.
$solution = array();
foreach ($chain as $position) {
$solution[] = $positions[$position];
}
print 'The solution is: ' . implode($solution, ' → ') . PHP_EOL;
/**
* Recursively test the clock based on a supplied position.
*
* @param array $values
* The current values of the clock.
* @param integer $i
* The current position of the clock.
* @param array $chain
* The current possible solution.
*
* @return
* An array of positions that represents a possible solution.
*/
function test_clock(array $values, $i, array $chain = array()) {
// If the value of the position we're in is 0, we've already tested it.
if ($values[$i] == 0) {
return $chain;
}
// Find the next two positions.
$position1 = $i + $values[$i];
$position2 = $i - $values[$i];
// Account for wraparound in the array.
if ($position1 > count($values) - 1) {
$position1 -= count($values);
}
if ($position2 < 0) {
$position2 += count($values);
}
// Mark this position as tested.
$values[$i] = 0;
$chain[] = $i;
// Test the first position.
$solution = test_clock($values, $position1, $chain);
// Don't bother checking the second position if the first is correct.
if (count($solution) == count($values)) {
return $solution;
}
// Test the second position.
return test_clock($values, $position2, $chain);
}
Drop that into a file, let's say hands-of-time.php
, and run it either off of a webserver or via PHP CLI:
$ php hands-of-time.php
The solution is: a → e → b → c → d → f
Change the $clock
array to whatever the puzzle is. For example, here's one of the larger clocks:
$clock = array(
'a' => 2,
'b' => 2,
'c' => 2,
'd' => 4,
'e' => 2,
'f' => 2,
'g' => 3,
'h' => 3,
'i' => 6,
'j' => 4,
'k' => 5,
'l' => 3,
);
And here's the output:
The solution is: a → k → f → h → e → g → j → b → d → l → i → c