"cat /proc/net/dev" and "ip -s link" show different statistics. Which one is lying?

Solution 1:

On a Squeeze machine, trust /proc/net/dev. It's a more straightforward and reliable way of looking at the same data.

For the particular case of the dropped count, I can't explain the exact issue, but I can observe it on other Squeeze boxes. If I cared, I would report it as a bug to Debian (and suggest someone does and reports back here).

Both take the number from the tx_dropped field of net_device_stats. In /proc/net/dev, the line is generated by dev_seq_printf_stats from net/core/dev.c.

ip goes, as usual, through netlink, and more precisely for network device statistics, rtnetlink. The structure passed to userspace, rtnl_link_stats.

The native structure uses unsigned longs, rtnetlink uses __u32, an more or less implicit conversion is done in copy_rtnl_link_stats.

It's pretty easy to catch the 32-bit version is being used from the beginning of the structure, rx_packets: whilst /proc/net/dev shows 1258629839430, ip shows 244248462, which corresponds roughly to the last 32 bits (plus a few more bytes between commands); same thing with the packet count.

Here's the number crunching for those 2 first fields:

% echo '1258629839430 % (2^32)'|bc; echo 244248462
204421702
244248462
% echo '12545003042 % (2^32)'|bc; echo 3955476484 
3955068450
3955476484

Things got better around the introduction of IFLA_STATS64:

• in the kernel (from commit 10708f37ae729baba9b67bd134c3720709d4ae62, available upstream in v2.6.35 and later)
• in iproute2 (from commit 8864ac9dc5bd5ce049280337deb21191673a02d0, available upstream in v2.6.33-36 and later).