Solution 1:

Just add comma ',' if you want multiple valid users. See line that I used below.

valid users = @group1, @group2

Solution 2:

I wound up adding the users from the most restricted group Directors to the Staff and Interns group as well as their original group. Then I added the users from the Staff group to the Interns group as well as their original group.

The line I used was a simple

valid users = @group_name