Are my disks within this MSA storage failing?

Yes, you have some prefailure warnings, get them swapped out ASAP.


I recommend that you search for more information about this error before you start replacing any hdd's.

Info from HP support site about this: http://h30499.www3.hp.com/t5/ProLiant-Servers-ML-DL-SL/hard-drive-error-640006-on-ML350G5/td-p/5597711#.UGQfJFEv-J8

If you don't care about the cost of replacing the disks, replace them as soon as you can. You could always do the diagnostics of the disks on a second test server later, just to determine if your disk actually are bad or if it's the HPID Tool that is reporting false positives.