Spawned under water in Bedrock edition?
I created a brand new world in minecraft-bedrock-edition (v1.17.10) to be surprised with a spawn point that is under water:
This was a shock to me since I've never seen it before, so I began researching it. It has happened to others (here is an example that I still have open), and it doesn't appear to be that rare of an occurrence. However, I couldn't find a definitive explanation on whether this was a bug, or by design. So after some more digging, I reviewed the spawn rules documentation to reveal that it's possible to specify that an entity can spawn under water, within a behavior pack:
Name | Description |
---|---|
minecraft:spawns_underwater |
This component allows the mob to spawn underwater. Adding the component sets the value of it to be true, removing it causes the mob to stop spawning underwater. |
I thought this was awesome, and since I'm using the default behavior and resource packs, I pulled up the vanilla packs to review them, and... there's no spawn rules contained in the vanilla pack for the player.
Is there something, somewhere, that explicitly defines that a player can spawn under water in minecraft-bedrock-edition?
Note: Just-in-case it's important, the world is in creative mode with a seed of -1265590396
and, the following options, experiments, and cheats are enabled: Friendly Fire
, Show Coordinates
, Fire Spreads
, TNT Explodes
, Mob Loot
, Natural Regeneration
, Tile Drops
, Caves and Cliffs
, Holiday Creator Features
, Creation of Custom Biomes
, Additional Modding Capabilities
, Upcoming Creator Features
, Enable GameTest Framework
, Activate Cheats
, Do Daylight Cycle
, Mob Spawning
, Mob Griefing
, Entities Drop Loot
, Weather Cycle
, Command Blocks Eanbled
.
According to Minecraft wiki:
The player spawns within a 5-block radius of the point selected in the chosen biome, sometimes resulting in the player spawning outside the intended spawn biome, ending up in a beach, river, or swamp biome. It is also possible (but rare) for a player to spawn initially underwater and start drowning
However, it was labeled by several users as a bug on MCPE, and it's still unresolved. It's possible this could be true also for other platforms.