Boolean vs tinyint(1) for boolean values in MySQL

What column type is best to use in a MySQL database for boolean values? I use boolean but my colleague uses tinyint(1).

Solution 1:

These data types are synonyms.

Solution 2:

I am going to take a different approach here and suggest that it is just as important for your fellow developers to understand your code as it is for the compiler/database to. Using boolean may do the same thing as using tinyint, however it has the advantage of semantically conveying what your intention is, and that's worth something.

If you use a tinyint, it's not obvious that the only values you should see are 0 and 1.
A boolean is ALWAYS true or false.

Solution 3:

boolean isn't a distinct datatype in MySQL; it's just a synonym for tinyint. See this page in the MySQL manual. See the quotes and examples down below from the dev.mysql.com/doc/

BOOL, BOOLEAN These types are synonyms for TINYINT(1). A value of zero is considered false. Nonzero values are considered true:

    mysql> SELECT IF(0, 'true', 'false');
    +------------------------+
    | IF(0, 'true', 'false') |
    +------------------------+
    | false                  |
    +------------------------+
    mysql> SELECT IF(1, 'true', 'false');
    +------------------------+
    | IF(1, 'true', 'false') |
    +------------------------+
    | true                   |
    +------------------------+
    mysql> SELECT IF(2, 'true', 'false');
    +------------------------+
    | IF(2, 'true', 'false') |
    +------------------------+
    | true                   |
    +------------------------+

However, the values TRUE and FALSE are merely aliases for 1 and 0, respectively, as shown here:

mysql> SELECT IF(0 = FALSE, 'true', 'false');
+--------------------------------+
| IF(0 = FALSE, 'true', 'false') |
+--------------------------------+
| true                           |
+--------------------------------+
mysql> SELECT IF(1 = TRUE, 'true', 'false');
+-------------------------------+
| IF(1 = TRUE, 'true', 'false') |
+-------------------------------+
| true                          |
+-------------------------------+
mysql> SELECT IF(2 = TRUE, 'true', 'false');
+-------------------------------+
| IF(2 = TRUE, 'true', 'false') |
+-------------------------------+
| false                         |
+-------------------------------+
mysql> SELECT IF(2 = FALSE, 'true', 'false');
+--------------------------------+
| IF(2 = FALSE, 'true', 'false') |
+--------------------------------+
| false                          |
+--------------------------------+

The last two statements display the results shown because 2 is equal to neither 1 nor 0.

Personally I would suggest use tinyint as a preference, because boolean doesn't do what you think it does from the name, so it makes for potentially misleading code. But at a practical level, it really doesn't matter -- they both do the same thing, so you're not gaining or losing anything by using either.