Initializing std::tuple from initializer list

Solution 1:

Initializer lists aren't relevant for tuples.

I think that you're confusing two different uses of curly braces in C++0x.

1. initializer_list<T> is a homogeneous collection (all members must be of the same type, so not relevant for std::tuple)
2. Uniform initialization is where curly brackets are used in order to construct all kinds of objects; arrays, PODs and classes with constructors. Which also has the benefit of solving the most vexing parse)

Here's a simplified version:

std::tuple<int, char> t = { 1, '1' }; 
// error: converting to 'std::tuple<int, char>' from initializer list would use
// explicit constructor 'std::tuple<_T1, _T2>::tuple(_U1&&, _U2&&) 
// [with _U1 = int, _U2 = char, _T1 = int, _T2 = char]'

std::tuple<int, char> t { 1, '1' }; // note no assignment
// OK, but not an initializer list, uniform initialization

The error message says is that you're trying to implicitly call the constructor but it's an explicit constructor so you can't.

Basically what you're trying to do is something like this:

struct A { 
    explicit A(int) {}
};

A a0 = 3;
// Error: conversion from 'int' to non-scalar type 'A' requested

A a1 = {3}; 
// Error: converting to 'const A' from initializer list would use 
// explicit constructor 'A::A(int)'

A a2(3); // OK C++98 style
A a3{3}; // OK C++0x Uniform initialization