Filtering an array with a function that returns a promise

Given

let arr = [1,2,3];

function filter(num) {
  return new Promise((res, rej) => {
    setTimeout(() => {
      if( num === 3 ) {
        res(num);
      } else {
        rej();
      }
    }, 1);
  });
 }

 function filterNums() {
   return Promise.all(arr.filter(filter));
 }

 filterNums().then(results => {
   let l = results.length;
   // length should be 1, but is 3
 });

The length is 3 because Promises are returned, not values. Is there a way to filter the array with a function that returns a Promise?

Note: For this example, fs.stat has been replaced with setTimeout, see https://github.com/silenceisgolden/learn-esnext/blob/array-filter-async-function/tutorials/array-filter-with-async-function.js for the specific code.


Solution 1:

Here is a 2017 elegant solution using async/await :

Very straightforward usage:

const results = await filter(myArray, async num => {
  await doAsyncStuff()
  return num > 2
})

The helper function (copy this into your web page):

async function filter(arr, callback) {
  const fail = Symbol()
  return (await Promise.all(arr.map(async item => (await callback(item)) ? item : fail))).filter(i=>i!==fail)
}

Demo:

// Async IIFE
(async function() {
  const myArray = [1, 2, 3, 4, 5]

  // This is exactly what you'd expect to write 
  const results = await filter(myArray, async num => {
    await doAsyncStuff()
    return num > 2
  })

  console.log(results)
})()


// Arbitrary asynchronous function
function doAsyncStuff() {
  return Promise.resolve()
}


// The helper function
async function filter(arr, callback) {
  const fail = Symbol()
  return (await Promise.all(arr.map(async item => (await callback(item)) ? item : fail))).filter(i=>i!==fail)
}

I'll even throw in a CodePen.

Solution 2:

As mentioned in the comments, Array.prototype.filter is synchronous and therefore does not support Promises.

Since you can now (theoretically) subclass built-in types with ES6, you should be able to add your own asynchronous method which wraps the existing filter function:

Note: I've commented out the subclassing, because it's not supported by Babel just yet for Arrays

class AsyncArray /*extends Array*/ {
  constructor(arr) {
    this.data = arr; // In place of Array subclassing
  }

  filterAsync(predicate) {
     // Take a copy of the array, it might mutate by the time we've finished
    const data = Array.from(this.data);
    // Transform all the elements into an array of promises using the predicate
    // as the promise
    return Promise.all(data.map((element, index) => predicate(element, index, data)))
    // Use the result of the promises to call the underlying sync filter function
      .then(result => {
        return data.filter((element, index) => {
          return result[index];
        });
      });
  }
}
// Create an instance of your subclass instead
let arr = new AsyncArray([1,2,3,4,5]);
// Pass in your own predicate
arr.filterAsync(async (element) => {
  return new Promise(res => {
    setTimeout(() => {
      res(element > 3);
    }, 1);
  });
}).then(result => {
  console.log(result)
});

Babel REPL Demo