Is the Lance Shield as strong or stronger than the Gunlance Shield?

I'm thinking of starting to use the Lance or Gunlance, and wasn't sure about this.

So basically:

  • Do they block the same?
  • Does one block certain attack the other can't?
  • When blocking, do you take more damage with one than the other?

I'm just concerned about the weapons themselves mostly. If armor skills change one more drastically than the other, please include that.


Solution 1:

For the most part, the Lance and Gunlance shields function exactly the same way; they'll block the same attacks, take the same amount of chip damage, and block animation. Armor skills treat them the same way, too; Guard and Guard Up will do the same things, etc.

The only difference is that the Lance has more defensive moves available; the Power Guard most notably.

In terms of defensive strength, they're exactly the same. When you add in the weapon, though, Lance gives a bit more defensive versatility.

Source