10 gigabit networks: Decieding between fiber and twisted pair

Solution 1:

If you're using copper, your cable runs will be limited. (15m for twin-ax, 55m for STP/UTP). Also, bear in mind that you will need Cat6 if you go with the STP/UTP option. (Cat6a will allow you to run 10G/copper at distances of 100m).

The other thing you should look into is the relative cost of hardware. Most 10G fiber line cards are modular, with the optics being separate. This increases your initial outlay, but reduces replacement costs as generally optics fail at a much higher rate than line cards. I don't know if there are modular copper cards, and what the relative failure rates of transceivers vs. line cards are when using copper.

My bias would be fiber for all infrastructure (i.e. network-network) links. Having recently participated in a new DC build where we used Cat6 for all host connections, (even though we're only running at 1G), I'm not convinced by it. The cables are heavier and more difficult to run (less flex in them). The connectors, despite supposedly being the same spec as RJ45, seem to be slightly larger, which makes insertion/removal difficult.

Solution 2:

  1. Cost

  2. twisted pair is much more susceptible for interferences

I recently read an interesting article (but it is german http://www.heise.de/netze/10-Gigabit-pro-Sekunde-ueber-Kupfer--/artikel/96475)

Solution 3:

Most of the key issues have been mentioned - Fiber is easier to handle, weighs less, makes for a much neater environment and has better range (generally). As LapTop006 mentioned one consequence of this is that the port density on switches is generally higher for fiber, you'll find that many modular switches support a higher SFP+ port count than either CX4 (Twin-AX) or 10GBase-T (STP).

One other key difference is that at the moment 10GBase-T consumes more power per port than CX4 and in turn CX4 consumes more power than SFP+. That may not be of significance if you are only connecting up a few links but if you are building out a significant infrastructure then this may be something you need to pay attention to.