Redshift. Convert comma delimited values into rows
Solution 1:
A slight improvement over the existing answer is to use a second "numbers" table that enumerates all of the possible list lengths and then use a cross join
to make the query more compact.
Redshift does not have a straightforward method for creating a numbers table that I am aware of, but we can use a bit of a hack from https://www.periscope.io/blog/generate-series-in-redshift-and-mysql.html to create one using row numbers.
Specifically, if we assume the number of rows in cmd_logs
is larger than the maximum number of commas in the user_action
column, we can create a numbers table by counting rows. To start, let's assume there are at most 99 commas in the user_action
column:
select
(row_number() over (order by true))::int as n
into numbers
from cmd_logs
limit 100;
If we want to get fancy, we can compute the number of commas from the cmd_logs
table to create a more precise set of rows in numbers
:
select
n::int
into numbers
from
(select
row_number() over (order by true) as n
from cmd_logs)
cross join
(select
max(regexp_count(user_action, '[,]')) as max_num
from cmd_logs)
where
n <= max_num + 1;
Once there is a numbers
table, we can do:
select
user_id,
user_name,
split_part(user_action,',',n) as parsed_action
from
cmd_logs
cross join
numbers
where
split_part(user_action,',',n) is not null
and split_part(user_action,',',n) != '';
Solution 2:
Another idea is to transform your CSV string into JSON first, followed by JSON extract, along the following lines:
... '["' || replace( user_action, '.', '", "' ) || '"]' AS replaced
... JSON_EXTRACT_ARRAY_ELEMENT_TEXT(replaced, numbers.i) AS parsed_action
Where "numbers" is the table from the first answer. The advantage of this approach is the ability to use built-in JSON functionality.