How do I identify a item in Diablo 3 on console?
On console, the identification tool-tip is slightly misleading.
While it says "press X", you actually have to hold X. While you hold X, a progress bar will appear on the item. Once the bar fills up, the item will be identified.
Figured it out, so simple, just needed to HOLD DOWN X, rather then "pressing it" like it said on the screen.