Is "Socketed Thing That Should Not Be Of Razors" real or a bug?

Solution 1:

It's a real item; the base item is the "Thing That Should Not Be"; that is, something that's unnatural or shouldn't exist in this world. Seems appropriate for a Witch Doctor.

If it helps, the name of your particular item can be parsed as:

  • Socketed (prefix; adds a socket)

  • Thing That Should Not Be (base name)

  • Of Razors (suffix; adds thorns property)

Solution 2:

That looks real to me. I've never played a witch doctor, but occasionally witch doctor items drop, and they generally have crazy names like this one.