Mockito - difference between doReturn() and when()

I am currently in the process of using Mockito to mock my service layer objects in a Spring MVC application in which I want to test my Controller methods. However, as I have been reading on the specifics of Mockito, I have found that the methods doReturn(...).when(...) is equivalent to when(...).thenReturn(...). So, my question is what is the point of having two methods that do the same thing or what is the subtle difference between doReturn(...).when(...) and when(...).thenReturn(...)?

Any help would be appreciated.

The two syntaxes for stubbing are roughly equivalent. However, you can always use doReturn/when for stubbing; but there are cases where you can't use when/thenReturn. Stubbing void methods is one such. Others include use with Mockito spies, and stubbing the same method more than once.

One thing that when/thenReturn gives you, that doReturn/when doesn't, is type-checking of the value that you're returning, at compile time. However, I believe this is of almost no value - if you've got the type wrong, you'll find out as soon as you run your test.

I strongly recommend only using doReturn/when. There is no point in learning two syntaxes when one will do.

You may wish to refer to my answer at Forming Mockito "grammars" - a more detailed answer to a very closely related question.

Both approaches behave differently if you use a spied object (annotated with @Spy) instead of a mock (annotated with @Mock):

when(...) thenReturn(...) makes a real method call just before the specified value will be returned. So if the called method throws an Exception you have to deal with it / mock it etc. Of course you still get your result (what you define in thenReturn(...))
doReturn(...) when(...) does not call the method at all.

Example:

public class MyClass {
     protected String methodToBeTested() {
           return anotherMethodInClass();
     }

     protected String anotherMethodInClass() {
          throw new NullPointerException();
     }
}

Test:

@Spy
private MyClass myClass;

// ...

// would work fine
doReturn("test").when(myClass).anotherMethodInClass();

// would throw a NullPointerException
when(myClass.anotherMethodInClass()).thenReturn("test");

The Mockito javadoc seems to tell why use doReturn() instead of when() Use doReturn() in those rare occasions when you cannot use Mockito.when(Object).

Beware that Mockito.when(Object) is always recommended for stubbing because it is argument type-safe and more readable (especially when stubbing consecutive calls).

Here are those rare occasions when doReturn() comes handy:

1. When spying real objects and calling real methods on a spy brings side effects

List list = new LinkedList(); List spy = spy(list);

//Impossible: real method is called so spy.get(0) throws IndexOutOfBoundsException (the list is yet empty)

when(spy.get(0)).thenReturn("foo");

//You have to use doReturn() for stubbing: doReturn("foo").when(spy).get(0);

2. Overriding a previous exception-stubbing:

when(mock.foo()).thenThrow(new RuntimeException());

//Impossible: the exception-stubbed foo() method is called so RuntimeException is thrown. when(mock.foo()).thenReturn("bar");

//You have to use doReturn() for stubbing:

doReturn("bar").when(mock).foo(); Above scenarios shows a tradeoff of Mockito's elegant syntax. Note that the scenarios are very rare, though. Spying should be sporadic and overriding exception-stubbing is very rare. Not to mention that in general overridding stubbing is a potential code smell that points out too much stubbing.

Mockito - difference between doReturn() and when()

Related

Recent Posts