height: 100% or min-height: 100% for html and body elements?

While designing layouts I set the html, body elements' height to 100% but in some cases, this fails, so what should be used?

html, body {
   height: 100%;
}

or

html, body {
   min-height: 100%;
}

Well, this is not opinion based as each method has its own flaws, so what's the recommended way to go for and why?

Solution 1:

If you're trying to apply background images to html and body that fill up the entire browser window, neither. Use this instead:

html {
   height: 100%;
}

body {
   min-height: 100%;
}

My reasoning is given here (where I explain holistically how to apply backgrounds in this manner):

Incidentally, the reason why you have to specify height and min-height to html and body respectively is because neither element has any intrinsic height. Both are height: auto by default. It is the viewport that has 100% height, so height: 100% is taken from the viewport, then applied to body as a minimum to allow for scrolling of content.

The first way, using height: 100% on both, prevents body from expanding with its contents once they start to grow beyond the viewport height. Technically this doesn't prevent the content from scrolling, but it does cause body to leave a gap beneath the fold, which is usually undesirable.

The second way, using min-height: 100% on both, doesn't cause body to expand to the full height of html because min-height with a percentage doesn't work on body unless html has an explicit height.

For the sake of completeness, section 10 of CSS2.1 contains all the details, but it's an extremely convoluted read so you can skip it if you're not interested in anything beyond what I've explained here.

Solution 2:

You can use viewport height (vh) unit:

body {
    min-height: 100vh;
}

It is relative to screen, not to parent height, so you don't need html height: 100%.