Ways to ASSERT expressions at build time in C

Solution 1:

NEW ANSWER :

In my original answer (below), I had to have two different macros to support assertions in a function scope and at the global scope. I wondered if it was possible to come up with a single solution that would work in both scopes.

I was able to find a solution that worked for Visual Studio and Comeau compilers using extern character arrays. But I was able to find a more complex solution that works for GCC. But GCC's solution doesn't work for Visual Studio. :( But adding a '#ifdef __ GNUC __', it's easy to choose the right set of macros for a given compiler.

Solution:

#ifdef __GNUC__
#define STATIC_ASSERT_HELPER(expr, msg) \
    (!!sizeof \ (struct { unsigned int STATIC_ASSERTION__##msg: (expr) ? 1 : -1; }))
#define STATIC_ASSERT(expr, msg) \
    extern int (*assert_function__(void)) [STATIC_ASSERT_HELPER(expr, msg)]
#else
    #define STATIC_ASSERT(expr, msg)   \
    extern char STATIC_ASSERTION__##msg[1]; \
    extern char STATIC_ASSERTION__##msg[(expr)?1:2]
#endif /* #ifdef __GNUC__ */

Here are the error messages reported for STATIC_ASSERT(1==1, test_message); at line 22 of test.c:

GCC:

line 22: error: negative width in bit-field `STATIC_ASSERTION__test_message'

Visual Studio:

test.c(22) : error C2369: 'STATIC_ASSERTION__test_message' : redefinition; different subscripts
    test.c(22) : see declaration of 'STATIC_ASSERTION__test_message'

Comeau:

line 22: error: declaration is incompatible with
        "char STATIC_ASSERTION__test_message[1]" (declared at line 22)

ORIGINAL ANSWER :

I do something very similar to what Checkers does. But I include a message that'll show up in many compilers:

#define STATIC_ASSERT(expr, msg)               \
{                                              \
    char STATIC_ASSERTION__##msg[(expr)?1:-1]; \
    (void)STATIC_ASSERTION__##msg[0];          \
}

And for doing something at the global scope (outside a function) use this:

#define GLOBAL_STATIC_ASSERT(expr, msg)   \
  extern char STATIC_ASSERTION__##msg[1]; \
  extern char STATIC_ASSERTION__##msg[(expr)?1:2]

Solution 2:

There is an article by Ralf Holly that examines different options for static asserts in C.

He presents three different approaches:

• switch case values must be unique
• arrays must not have negative dimensions
• division by zero for constant expressions

His conclusion for the best implementation is this:

#define assert_static(e) \
    do { \
        enum { assert_static__ = 1/(e) }; \
    } while (0)

Solution 3:

Checkout boost's static assert