What's the 'Rails 4 Way' of finding some number of random records?

You'll want to use the order and limit methods instead. You can get rid of the all.

For PostgreSQL and SQLite:

User.order("RANDOM()").limit(10)

Or for MySQL:

User.order("RAND()").limit(10)

As the random function could change for different databases, I would recommend to use the following code:

User.offset(rand(User.count)).first

Of course, this is useful only if you're looking for only one record.

If you wanna get more that one, you could do something like:

User.offset(rand(User.count) - 10).limit(10)

The - 10 is to assure you get 10 records in case rand returns a number greater than count - 10.

Keep in mind you'll always get 10 consecutive records.

I think the best solution is really ordering randomly in database. But if you need to avoid specific random function from database, you can use pluck and shuffle approach.

For one record:

User.find(User.pluck(:id).shuffle.first)

For more than one record:

User.where(id: User.pluck(:id).sample(10))