Does killing Pigs raise Naughtiness as Webber?
Solution 1:
I have a game going as Webber, so I tried this out. Suitably adorned in football helmet and log suit, I walked up to a pig. He hit me. I whacked him with my spear until he died. I got 3 naughtiness. (I'm using the Always On Status mod.)
Another pig was nearby, so I walked up and attacked him, and when the battle was over, I got another 3 naughtiness, for a total of 6.
Killing pigs as Webber raises naughtiness, regardless of who hits first.