Counting DISTINCT over multiple columns

Is there a better way of doing a query like this:

SELECT COUNT(*) 
FROM (SELECT DISTINCT DocumentId, DocumentSessionId
      FROM DocumentOutputItems) AS internalQuery

I need to count the number of distinct items from this table but the distinct is over two columns.

My query works fine but I was wondering if I can get the final result using just one query (without using a sub-query)

Solution 1:

If you are trying to improve performance, you could try creating a persisted computed column on either a hash or concatenated value of the two columns.

Once it is persisted, provided the column is deterministic and you are using "sane" database settings, it can be indexed and / or statistics can be created on it.

I believe a distinct count of the computed column would be equivalent to your query.

Solution 2:

Edit: Altered from the less-than-reliable checksum-only query I've discovered a way to do this (in SQL Server 2005) that works pretty well for me and I can use as many columns as I need (by adding them to the CHECKSUM() function). The REVERSE() function turns the ints into varchars to make the distinct more reliable

SELECT COUNT(DISTINCT (CHECKSUM(DocumentId,DocumentSessionId)) + CHECKSUM(REVERSE(DocumentId),REVERSE(DocumentSessionId)) )
FROM DocumentOutPutItems

Solution 3:

What is it about your existing query that you don't like? If you are concerned that DISTINCT across two columns does not return just the unique permutations why not try it?

It certainly works as you might expect in Oracle.

SQL> select distinct deptno, job from emp
  2  order by deptno, job
  3  /

    DEPTNO JOB
---------- ---------
        10 CLERK
        10 MANAGER
        10 PRESIDENT
        20 ANALYST
        20 CLERK
        20 MANAGER
        30 CLERK
        30 MANAGER
        30 SALESMAN

9 rows selected.


SQL> select count(*) from (
  2  select distinct deptno, job from emp
  3  )
  4  /

  COUNT(*)
----------
         9

SQL>

edit

I went down a blind alley with analytics but the answer was depressingly obvious...

SQL> select count(distinct concat(deptno,job)) from emp
  2  /

COUNT(DISTINCTCONCAT(DEPTNO,JOB))
---------------------------------
                                9

SQL>

edit 2

Given the following data the concatenating solution provided above will miscount:

col1  col2
----  ----
A     AA
AA    A

So we to include a separator...

select col1 + '*' + col2 from t23
/

Obviously the chosen separator must be a character, or set of characters, which can never appear in either column.

Solution 4:

To run as a single query, concatenate the columns, then get the distinct count of instances of the concatenated string.

SELECT count(DISTINCT concat(DocumentId, DocumentSessionId)) FROM DocumentOutputItems;

In MySQL you can do the same thing without the concatenation step as follows:

SELECT count(DISTINCT DocumentId, DocumentSessionId) FROM DocumentOutputItems;

This feature is mentioned in the MySQL documentation:

http://dev.mysql.com/doc/refman/5.7/en/group-by-functions.html#function_count-distinct

Solution 5:

How about something like:

select count(*)
from
  (select count(*) cnt
   from DocumentOutputItems
   group by DocumentId, DocumentSessionId) t1

Probably just does the same as you are already though but it avoids the DISTINCT.