How to verify new digits of $\pi$?
Solution 1:
Since you allow any base, (16 in particular) and randomized algorithm, you can use the Bailey-Borwein-Plouffe formula which allows you to compute the $n^{th}$ digit of $\pi$, without having to compute the earlier $n-1$ digits! (Alas, such a algorithm seems to have been discovered only for base-16.)
All Alice needs to do is pick "some" random digits and compare.