MySQL - SELECT all columns WHERE one column is DISTINCT
I'm very sorry if the question seems too basic.
I've surfed entire Internet and StackOverflow for a finished solution, and did not find anything that I can understand, and can't write it myself, so have to ask it here.
I have a MySQL database.
It has a table named "posted".
It has 8 columns.
I need to output this result:
SELECT DISTINCT link FROM posted WHERE ad='$key' ORDER BY day, month
But I need not only the "link" column, but also other columns for this row.
Like for every row returned with this query I also need to know its "id" in the table, "day" and "month" values etc.
Please tell me what should I read to make it, or how to make it.
Please keep it as simple as possible, as I'm not an expert in MySQL.
Edit: I tried this:
SELECT DISTINCT link,id,day,month FROM posted WHERE ad='$key' ORDER BY day, month
It doesn't work. It returns too many rows. Say there are 10 rows with same links, but different day/month/id. This script will return all 10, and I want only the first one (for this link).
Solution 1:
The problem comes from instinctively believing that DISTINCT
is a local pre-modifier for a column.
Hence, you "should" be able to type
XXbadXX SELECT col1, DISTINCT col2 FROM mytable XXbadXX
and have it return unique values for col
2. Sadly, no. DISTINCT
is actually a global post-modifier for SELECT
, that is, as opposed to SELECT ALL
(returning all answers) it is SELECT DISTINCT
(returning all unique answers). So a single DISTINCT
acts on ALL the columns that you give it.
This makes it real hard to use DISTINCT
on a single column, while getting the other columns, without doing major extremely ugly backflips.
The correct answer is to use a GROUP BY
on the columns that you want to have unique answers: SELECT col1, col2 FROM mytable GROUP BY col2
will give you arbitrary unique col2
rows, with their col1
data as well.
Solution 2:
I tried this:
SELECT DISTINCT link,id,day,month FROM posted WHERE ad='$key' ORDER BY day, month
It doesn't work. It returns too many rows. Say there are 10 rows with same links, but different day/month/id. This script will return all 10, and I want only the first one (for this link).
What you're asking doesn't make sense.
Either you want the distinct value of all of link, id, day, month
, or you need to find a criterion to choose which of the values of id, day, month
you want to use, if you just want at most one distinct value of link
.
Otherwise, what you're after is similar to MySQL's hidden columns in GROUP BY
/HAVING
statements, which is non-standard SQL, and can actually be quite confusing.
You could in fact use a GROUP BY link
if it made sense to pick any row for a given link
value.
Alternatively, you could use a sub-select to pick the row with the minimal id
for a each link
value (as described in this answer):
SELECT link, id, day, month FROM posted
WHERE (link, id) IN
(SELECT link, MIN(id) FROM posted ad='$key' GROUP BY link)
Solution 3:
SELECT Id, Link, Day, Month FROM Posted
WHERE Id IN(
SELECT Min(Id) FROM Posted GROUP BY Link)
Solution 4:
If what your asking is to only show rows that have 1 link for them then you can use the following:
SELECT * FROM posted WHERE link NOT IN
(SELECT link FROM posted GROUP BY link HAVING COUNT(LINK) > 1)
Again this is assuming that you want to cut out anything that has a duplicate link.