Weak tangent but not a strong tangent

Question: Show that $\alpha(t)=(t^3,t^2)$, $t\in \Bbb R$, has a weak tangent but not a strong tangent at $t=0$.

Definitions from this answer:

(Weak tangent) $\alpha: I \to \Bbb R^3$ has a weak tangent at $t_0 \in I$, if the line determined by $\alpha(t_0 + h)$ and $\alpha(t_0)$ has a limit position when $h \to 0$.

(Strong tangent) $\alpha: I \to \Bbb R^3$ has a strong tangent at $t_0 \in I$, if the line determined by $\alpha(t_0 + h)$ and $\alpha(t_0 + k)$ has a limit position when $h \to 0$ and $k \to 0$.

My query:

I'm not really clear what argument to use to demonstrate this. The weak tangent is the line joining $\alpha(t_0)$ and $\alpha(t_0+h)$, which is $$ (\lambda(x(t_0+h)-x(t_0))+x(t_0), \lambda(y(t_0+h)-y(t_0))+y(t_0)) $$ If $t_0=0$ then $x(t_0)=0$ so this becomes $$ (\lambda h^3, \lambda h^2) $$ The strong tangent is $$ (\lambda(x(t_0+h)-x(t_0+k))+x(t_0+k), \lambda(y(t_0+h)-y(t_0+k))+y(t_0+k)) $$ $$ =(\lambda (h^3-k^3)+k^3,\lambda (h^2-k^2)+k^2) $$ As $h,k\rightarrow0$ this seems badly defined. But how can I make this argument precise?

Also, what is the intuitive meaning of the strong and weak tangents?

[This is exercise 1-3-7 of Differential Geometry of Curves and Surfaces by Do Carmo.]

Solution 1:

Weak tangent

Notice that the slope of $(\lambda h^3, \lambda h^2)$ tends to $\infty$ as $h\to 0$, meaning that the line direction approaches vertical. Since the line always passes through $(0,0)$, this means it has a limiting position (the $y$ axis).

Strong tangent

If it exists, it has to be the same as the weak tangent, because if the double limit exists, iterated limit "$k\to 0$ then $h\to 0$" exists and is equal to it. However, approaching via $h=-k$ you will find that the lines stay horizontal.

Intuitive meaning

• Strong tangent: if you walk along the curve and someone is walking along the tangent line with the same speed, you can spend some time walking together and holding hands.

• Weak tangent: looks like strong tangent at first, but at the point of tangency there is a break-up and someone goes away in the opposite direction.