Must ASP.NET MVC Controller Methods Return ActionResult?

You can absolutely use specific return types, even though most examples on the web seems to return the ActionResult. The only time I would return the ActionResult class is when different paths of the action method returns different subtypes.

Steven Sanderson also recommends returning specific types in his book Pro ASP.NET MVC Framework. Take a look at the quote below:

This action method specifically declares that it returns an instance of ViewResult. It would work just the same if instead the method return type was ActionResult (the base class for all action results). In fact, some ASP.NET MVC programmers declare all their action methods as returning a nonspecific ActionResult, even if they know for sure that it will always return one particular subclass. However, it's a well-established principle in object-oriented programming that methods should return the most specific type they can (as well as accepting the most general parameter types they can). Following this principle maximizes convenience and flexibility for code that calls your method, such as your unit tests.

Always return the most accurate type you can return. So you should return a ViewResult when the action always shows a view. I would only use ActionResult when you return in ViewResult in some cases (invalid posted data) or a RedirectToRouteResult in other cases.

With some advanced actionfilter/executing scenario's, you can even return totally different things that have nothing to do with ActionResult.

[Partial answer]: You don't always return ActionResult, no. Here's a list of some other results you can return:

ViewResult
PartialViewResult
RedirectResult
RedirectToRouteResult
ContentResult
JsonResult
JavaScriptResult
FileResult
EmptyResult

See docs for more info.

Maybe that'll help a little. Good luck!

Yes, you can define your action like: public ViewResult Index(). But sometimes your action can return different results (it is impossible without declaring result as base ActionResult class). For example:

public ActionResult Show()
{
    ...

    if(Request.IsAjaxRequest())
    {
        return PartialView(...);
    }

    return View(...);
}

or:

public ActionResult Show()
{
    ...

    try
    {
        ...
    }
    catch(Exception)
    {
        return RedirectToAction(...);
    }

    return View(...);
}

Must ASP.NET MVC Controller Methods Return ActionResult?

Related

Recent Posts